skip to main content
Aug 2020

Lifetime ISA vs Investment ISA

Lifetime ISA vs Investment ISA

Are you looking to put your hard-earned cash into an ISA with a long term saving view? Wondering whether you should choose an Investment ISA or a Lifetime ISA? We’ve broken down what you need to know to make your choice. 

What is a Lifetime ISA?

Lifetime ISAs were launched in 2017, and are a great opportunity for savers to get excellent returns on the money they put in – with some fairly strict boundaries.

The government will give an account holder a 25% bonus of the amount you put into the account each year. There is a limit imposed on how much you can put into the account per year, which currently stands at £4000 per year. This means you can stand to gain an attractive £1000 bonus every year.

Lifetime ISAs are intentionally designed to be long-term saving: account holders can only take money out at two different points.

Firstly, you can withdraw money from a LISA (Lifetime ISA) when you purchase your first home. This is designed to help first time buyers build up a deposit and get on the property ladder.

Secondly, you can withdraw money from a LISA after the age of 55, meaning that money you put into the account is earmarked for retirement age.

Withdrawals made at any other point could be subject to penalties, and will lose the 25% bonus from the government.

What is an Investment ISA?

An investment ISA (also known as a Stocks and Shares ISA) does what is says on the tin. It is an ISA account which allows you to invest money (up to a certain amount) without paying tax on the returns you gain each year.

The amount you can put into an investment ISA has no limit beyond the yearly amount stipulated by the government which covers all ISAs.

The tax allowance for the tax year 2020/2021 is £20,000, which can either be spread between different types of ISAs or – if you so choose – concentrated into one type of ISA.

In order to open an Investment ISA, you must be:

  • 18 or over
  • a citizen of the UK

You can choose to invest your money in various different funds depending on the platform you have chosen. Because of the excellent tax benefits, this is a very popular form of long-term saving.

Why would I choose a Lifetime ISA?

There are lots of reasons you could choose a lifetime ISA, including…

  • If you’re saving for your first home, the 25% bonus from the government can be a huge help towards
  • If you want to lock your money away in long-term savings, with a very large government bonus, to ensure you have a good-sized income when you retire, then having a LISA is one of the best ways you can make your money work for you.
  • The 25% bonus from the government is the best possible return for your money, and is much higher than any interest rates you will get with an Investment ISA.
  • Keeping your money in a long-term saving account in one place makes it easy to keep a track of.

Why would I choose an Investment ISA?

There are lots of reasons you could choose an Investment ISA, including...

  • Lifetime ISAs lock your money away – if you’re looking for the truest long-term savings then that is the account for you. You will not be able to access the money before you are 55 without suffering penalties. However, with an Investment ISA, there are shorter terms available – you could gain good returns for locking your money away for only five years.
  • You are only allowed one LISA per person, however you can have as many Investment ISAs as you wish (as long as you only open one Stocks and Shares ISA per year).
  • If you are investment savvy, there is a vast amount of variety in the funds and shares you could invest in.

Do I have to choose between the two?

No – you are able to have and benefit from both types of account.

With a yearly allowance of £20,000 that you can put into a tax-free ISA wrapper, you can spread this across many different types of ISAs. However, the limitations that are placed within this are:

  • You can only open one ISA of each type per year
  • You can only put £4000 into a Lifetime ISA every year

Read more about Investment ISAs here.

Read more about Lifetime ISAs here. 

Investment Fund Supermarket ISAs

ii ACE 30 investments

from Interactive Investor

Allows ISA Transfers
  • Protection Scheme: FSCS
  • Fund Choice: 30 Ethical Investments
  • Invest From: £25 pm or £100 single

Why we like it: The UK's first rated list of ethical investments to help you align investments with your personal values. Building your investment portfolio can be tough – and it is even more difficult when you want to choose ethical investments. That can mean a lot of research. The ii ACE 30 makes the job easier for you.Interactive Investor have selected 30 funds, investment trusts and ETFs that they believe offer high-quality choices, across a broad variety of markets.

Important: Please remember the value of your investment and any income from it may fall as well as rise and is not guaranteed. You may get back less than you invest.

Selected ISAs

Investment ISA

from Nutmeg

Allows ISA Transfers
  • Protection Scheme: FSCS
  • Fund Choice: Discretionary investment management
  • Invest From: Min. £500 single

Why we like it: Get an intelligent stocks & shares ISA portfolio - Choose a portfolio that's fully managed by our expert team or a fixed allocation portfolio. No tie-ins, no set-up fees, no exit charges. Easy, online set up in minutes. Start with as little as £500. Portfolio management fees of 0.45%-0.75% up to £100k. 0.25%-0.35% beyond £100k. There are also underlying investment charges, see our fees page. Plus, live chat, amazing customer support and brilliant investor tools and guides. Authorised and regulated by the FCA. Capital at risk. ISA rules apply
Investment Fund Supermarket ISAs

Interative Investor Stocks & Shares ISA

from Interactive Investor

Allows ISA Transfers
  • Protection Scheme: FSCS
  • Fund Choice: 40,000+ UK and global investments
  • Invest From: Any Lump Sum or £25 a month

Why we like it: An award-winning ISA that gives you complete control. The second largest platform in the UK with the widest choice of investment options in the market including funds, investment trusts, ETF’s and more. Open online in less than 10 minutes. Access to expert independent ideas and analysis. Low cost fees and trading.

Important: The value of your investments can rise as well as fall. You may get back less than you invested. If you’re unsure, we recommend you ask for independent advice.

Important Risk Information:

The value of investments can go down in value as well as up, so you could get back less than you invest. It is therefore important that you understand the risks and commitments. This website aims to provide information to help you make your own informed decisions. It does not provide personal advice based on your circumstances. If you are unsure of how suitable an investment is for you, please seek personal advice.

High Income ISAs

High income ISA ideas:

ISAs Products

Cash ISAs

Fixed Rate & Instant Access ISAs:

Cash ISAs: 

Stocks & Shares ISAs

Types of Stocks and Shares ISA include: 

Stocks and Shares ISAs

Latest News

What is a Peer to Peer ISA?

18th September 2020

A Peer to Peer ISA sounds complicated – but to the experienced and keen investor, it can be a great way to diversify your portfolio, try a new, innovative form of investing, while benefiting from the tax benefits associated with an ISA account. But what exactly is a Peer to Peer ISA, and which ones should you be looking at? 

Newsletter Signup

Sign up to our Newsletter to get exclusive news and offers direct to your inbox.

About us is a trading style of Fair Investment Company.

We've been comparing and recommending ISAs for many years so you can trust you're in good hands.

About us

4.74 Average

23 Reviews


I found the way the different options are presented very clear - much more useful than some other comparison sites. I sent it to my daughter as well.


Very informative, find myself a good ISA account with best return in terms of interest.


Easy to use website and up to date. Saved the link on my tablet.

Rob Holden

The website was very useful and informative.

Andrew Johnson

ISA can be confusing at first and this site includes a useful and helpful introduction into the world of ISAs


Excellent website - clear and helpful information about different products - and a trustworthy partner.


Easy to use website and up to date. Saved the link on my tablet.


Really simple to use and all the information was clear with lots of products available. The interest calculator was really handy too. Have bookmarked and will definitely use again.

Hannah Gordon

This was a really user-friendly site, and was very helpful when it came to comparing accounts and choosing my 2016 ISA.


Easy to use website and up to date. Saved the link on my tablet.


If you wish to invest in an ISA this site has it all. A super comprehensive range of simply explained products from all the major companies.

Cristina Iacob

Very knowledgeble company with an extensive range of services, a great website with loads of useful information.


Nice graphics and easy to navigate

Dr Alan Rogan BSc PhD FCIOB FCABE Eur Ing

Good advice and professional approach


Very helpful for getting my annual ISA

Jonny Doulton

Clear, concise and very professional outfit with an excellent choice of market leading deals.

Paul Tissington not only helped narrow down my choices for a Junior ISA but also provided additional practical information that helped demystify the whole process.

Sunil Karadia

Just the site I needed, I have been looking for a suitable ISA for a while, but as there are so many to choose from, find it difficult to find the right one for me.

James Weatheritt

I found the information on very helpful and easy to understand. The site is easy to navigate and find what you're looking for.

Lisa Holden

I found very insightful and easy to navigate through. The content was useful and helped me make my ISA decision.

Neta Pourhosseini

I thought the information provided was easy to understand and very informative, I would recommend to friends for deffinite.